Where should we eat before the Mahaffey?
The Mahaffey Theater at the Duke Energy Center for the Arts is at 400 1st Street South, on the waterfront. Have dinner with us first: Shepherd's Pie with ground lamb and beef under golden potatoes and Irish cheddar, Cheri's Redhead Salad, named for Pete's mom, or the Hibernian Butcherboard.
Walking directions to the MahaffeyWhere can we go after the show?
A Proper Irish Coffee made Buena Vista style, a pour from a wall of over 100 whiskeys, or an Espresso Martini made with Ice Pik Vodka, Borghetti and Kahwa espresso. We're open until 1:30am Monday to Thursday and 3am on Friday and Saturday.
Drinks menu
Music by the fireplace.
Karaoke on Monday, open mic on Tuesday and live music Wednesday to Sunday.
5 – 8pm and 9pm – 1am
Hours
Earlier weekend openings on Premier League and Celtic matchdays.
Plan your visit
Getting here from Orlando, Sarasota and Tampa, parking and hours.
Open late
Until 3am Friday and Saturday, the late-night menu after 11pm.
Live music
Karaoke Monday, open mic Tuesday, live music Wednesday to Sunday.
Jannus Live nights
Before and after a show on our block.
Rays & Rowdies game days
Before the first pitch or kickoff, and after the final whistle.
Grand Prix weekend
March 5–7, 2027 on the streets of St. Pete.
Premier League in St. Pete
Early doors for the morning kickoffs.
Visiting from Ireland or the UK
Spice bag, curry chips, the Full Irish and a proper pint.
Our story
A grandmother's salon, a grandson's pub, and the block where the first airline took off.
The whiskey wall
Over 100 whiskeys, eight flights and the imperial pint.
The kitchen
What we make in house, and how.
Questions, answered
Parking, hours, food made in house, the whiskey wall.
Quick answers
Where should we go before or after a show at the Mahaffey Theater?
The Mahaffey is at 400 1st Street South, downtown with us. Have dinner here before the curtain and a Proper Irish Coffee or a whiskey after the show.
Is Mary Margaret's open after concerts?
Yes. We're open until 1:30am Monday to Thursday, 3am Friday and Saturday, and 12:30am Sunday, with live music until midnight Wednesday to Friday and until 1am Saturday. The full menu runs until 11pm, then the late-night menu.
Where do I park?
The Sundial Garage is close by, with its entrance on 2nd Street North between 1st and 2nd Avenue North. Metered street parking runs throughout downtown; on big event nights, allow extra time and check the posted signs.