Our Drinks
Cocktails
The Old-fashioned O'boland
Jameson Caskmate's simple syrup, angostura bitters & a dash o' Guinness Draught, garnished with filthy cherry & orange peel
The Proper B.V. Irish Coffee
A homage to Buena Vista Cafe's signature international Irish Coffee recipe with Tullamore DEW Irish Whiskey, Kahwa Coffee, brown sugar & cream
Paddy's Irish Martini
Equal parts Paddy's Irish Whiskey & Bailey's Irish Cream on the rocks
Mary's Margarita
A golden margarita with Gold Teuila, Gran Marnier and fresh lemon & lime juice
O'malley's Irish Breakfast Shooter
Jameson Whiskey & Buttershots served neat with an OJ & bacon chaser
Tully's Irish Mule
The Three Point Shot
Discover the new Juniper Summer Cocktail Menu at Mary Margaret’s Olde Irish Tavern—featuring refreshing gin cocktails, handcrafted botanicals, and build-your-own G&T creations in the heart of downtown St. Pete.
Summer Cocktails 2025
Rose Collins
$10.00
Glendalough Rose Gin, Rose Liquor, Lemon and Sugar topped with Club Soda
Bitter Bee
$12.00
Barr Hill Gin, Campari, Vermouth Bianco, Honey Syrup and fresh Lemon.
Speyside
$10.00
Tulchan Speyside Gin, Fresh Lemon Juice and Simple Syrup topped with bubbles .
Cucumber Gimlet
$12.00
Minke Irish Dry Gin, Fresh Lime Juice and Simple Syrup served up $12
G & T Bar
Build your own Gin and Tonic - $12 Base - Hendrick’s Gin or Hendrick’s Grand Cabaret +$2 (notes of stone fruit and sweet herbs) or Hendrick’s Oasium +$2 (notes of aromatic herbs and bright fruit) Choose a Bitter - Cucumber or Orange. Choose a Tonic - Lemon, Cucumber, Elderflower, Classic, Mediterranean, Pink.
Discover our Whiskey of the Month at Mary Margaret’s — a bold new pour chosen to surprise your palate and elevate your next visit.
Whiskey of the Month
Keeper's Heart
$6.00
Single Shot
Irish Espresso Martini
$12.00
Keeper’s Heart Irish/American Whiskey, Borghetti, brown sugar and espresso.
Keeper's Heart Flight
$15.00
Featuring the Irish/American, Irish/Bourbon, 10 Year Single Malt & Cask Strength